2018 Acura ILX Compare


2018 BMW 3 Series Compare


BMW or Acura — Who Makes the Better Car?

When it comes to purchasing a luxury vehicle it’s okay to be stringent with your desires and requirements. Your vehicle should be more than just a chariot– it should be your escape. BMW has been synonymous with luxury and class throughout its life, and as of late, BMW’s reliability has improved; however, it’s not always leather-bound-books and rich mahogany with them. Acura has built a reputation on reliable luxury that not only offers drivers an escape from the world around them, but will also deliver them safely and without fear of the expensive maintenance costs that are typically associated with luxury vehicles. After all, there must be a reason why the Acura MDX has been the best-selling third-row luxury SUV of all time, and the Acura RDX has been America’s #1 retail-selling compact luxury SUV for 2018!

Safest Luxury Cars and SUVs

Safety features play a big role in today’s automotive marketplace. With massive strides made in the fields of active and passive safety systems, along with driver assistance features, both Acura and BMW are at the top of innovation. However, in a ranking performed by Motor1.com, the Acura RLX was placed in the number one spot of the Safest Luxury Cars for 2018. Meanwhile, the Acura MDX took the number one spot for the Safest Luxury SUVs for 2018. Neither of those lists included a single mention of any BMW models. On top of that, the IIHS has awarded multiple Acura models as a Top Safety Pick and Top Safety Pick+.

2019 Acura RLX Acura Watch

Luxury Cars with the Best Resale Value

2019 Acura RDX A-Spec
With the automotive market changing quickly, as far as technology and performance are concerned, some drivers may be tempted to trade up to a newer model more often than not. Possessing a vehicle with a high resale value is a wise idea. Not only does a luxury car with a high resale value make it so you can sell your current model with less depreciation factored in, but if you are leasing a luxury vehicle, it’ll also help to keep your monthly payments down. Used Acura and BMW models are very sought after, but it seems that Acura models tend to depreciate at a slower rate than their fellow BMW models.

Autobytel ran an article covering the top “10 Car Brands with Best Resale Value”– which was not limited to luxury brands only. BMW was placed at number 8 on the list, while Acura came in three places better at number 5.

Along the same premise, Edmunds.com also ran a report of the vehicles and brands that held their resale value the best. The luxury brand with best resale value was honored to Porsche, but Acura came in as the honorable mention– BMW was nowhere to be found. In addition to that, the Acura ILX and Acura RDX were honorable mentions in their respected segments– neither lost to a BMW.

Most Affordable Luxury Cars

The aura that comes with luxury vehicles typically means a higher price tag. However, Acura has prided itself on offering luxury vehicles that are more obtainable without making sacrifices. NY Daily News released a list of the Top 10 Affordable Luxury Cars, and Acura fared much better than BMW.

  • 1st Place – Acura ILX
  • 4th Place – Acura TLX
  • 8th Place – BMW 3-Series
  • 9th Place – BMW 2-Series

If you look beyond that list, you will see that Acura models, in general, more often than not come in at a lower price point than their rival BMW models– and their equipped features are very comparable.

To strengthen the cause, Kelley Blue Book named Acura as the most affordable luxury brand to own– the Acura ILX also took first place in its segment. In their 2018 5-Year Cost to Own Awards they mention, “Acura enters 2018 with its third consecutive brand win in the 5-Year Cost to Own Awards. What’s its secret? The answer lies in Acura’s ability to make vehicles that are both luxurious and a great value.”

Scoring Factors:

  • Depreciation
  • Expected Fuel Costs
  • Finance and Insurance Fees
  • Maintenance and Repair Costs
  • State Fees for New Models
2018 Acura ILX driving through the mountains
2019 Acura TLX Driving
  • Best Luxury CPO (Certified Pre-Owned) Program

    Obtaining a luxury vehicle through a certified pre-owned program could be an enticing option for drivers looking to get behind the wheel of a luxury vehicle at a lower price point without sacrificing the peace of mind of reliability. Autotrader’s list of the 10 Best Luxury CPO Programs for 2018 covers the benefits that different manufacturers offer and why they are a top choice. BMW was not a recommendation, but Acura was present– and with good reason. Each Acura model that is deemed CPO has undergone extensive inspections, and even comes with warranties that apply to many aspects of the vehicle.

Awarded Luxury Vehicles

When you break down the details, Acura surpasses BMW in many aspects– and we feel that awards can speak loudly here.

Awarded Model / Brand


2019 Acura RDX

Wards 10 Best UX” Award for Innovative Tech

2018 Acura RDX

’10 Best Family Cars 2018′ List from Parents Magazine and Edmunds.com

Acura Brand

Autotrader’s 10-Best Luxury CPO Programs for 2018

Acura Brand & 2018 Acura ILX

Kelley Blue Book’s 5-Year Cost to Own Awards

2018 Acura MDX & RDX

U.S. News & World Report’s 2018 Best Cars for the Money

2018 Acura MDX

2018 AutoWeb Buyer’s Choice Award

2018 Acura MDX, RDX & TLX

2018 Consumer Guide® Automotive Best Buy Awards

Acura or BMW – Who makes the best luxury vehicles?

If you’re in the market for one of the best luxury vehicles the decision ultimately comes down to you and what your requirements are; however, Acura has been a very trusted brand throughout the years when it comes to reliability, affordability, technology, and safety. We will say, BMW is well respected and is certainly a worthy rival when it comes to quality of vehicles. However, time and time again Acura has surpassed BMW when it comes to value, safety, features, and various other award winning areas. Before you find yourself standing in a BMW dealership, experience the exquisite lineup of Acura’s sport sedans and luxury SUVs at a Chicagoland Acura Dealer near you– once behind the wheel, you may not want to get out.

Chicagoland Acura Dealers 41.8819, 87.6278.